Players for this game come from the audience, and are randomly drawn as a raffle prize, playing for each of the two teams. Players are given three answers to a random category, with one of them being a lie. Contestants are competing with each other to determine which one is the lie. If the player who buzzes in first guesses correctly, they are awarded one point. At the end of the game the person with the most points wins. If at the end of Game On! the teams are tied, the winner of the audience game will break the tie.